What Is Mixed Methods Research?
Mixed methods research combines qualitative and quantitative approaches within a single study or programme of inquiry. Rather than being limited to numbers or narratives alone, mixed methods researchers leverage both to answer complex research questions more comprehensively.
In Canadian academia, mixed methods research has grown significantly in popularity, particularly in education, health sciences, social work, and interdisciplinary programmes. The approach is well-suited to the kinds of complex, contextualised research questions that characterise much Canadian scholarship.
Why Choose Mixed Methods?
Complementarity
Quantitative data can reveal patterns and relationships, while qualitative data can explain why those patterns exist. Together, they provide a more complete understanding.
Triangulation
Using multiple methods to study the same phenomenon increases confidence in findings when results converge.
Development
Results from one method can inform the design or interpretation of the other.
Expansion
Mixed methods can broaden the scope of your study by addressing different but related questions through different methods.
Core Mixed Methods Designs
Explanatory Sequential Design (QUAN → qual)
- Phase 1: Collect and analyse quantitative data
- Phase 2: Use qualitative data to explain or elaborate on quantitative results
- Example: Surveying 500 Canadian nurses about burnout (quantitative), then interviewing 20 nurses with the highest and lowest scores to understand their experiences (qualitative)
Exploratory Sequential Design (qual → QUAN)
- Phase 1: Collect and analyse qualitative data to explore a phenomenon
- Phase 2: Use qualitative findings to develop or test a quantitative instrument
- Example: Conducting focus groups with international students at Canadian universities to understand adjustment challenges (qualitative), then developing and administering a survey to measure adjustment across institutions (quantitative)
Convergent Parallel Design (QUAN + qual)
- Collect quantitative and qualitative data simultaneously
- Analyse each dataset independently
- Merge results for comparison and integration
- Example: Simultaneously surveying and interviewing teachers about inclusive education practices at Ontario schools, then comparing and integrating findings
Embedded Design
- One method is nested within a larger study using a different method
- Example: Embedding qualitative interviews within an RCT to understand participant experiences of an intervention
Transformative Design
- A social justice framework guides all methodological decisions
- Example: Using Indigenous research methodologies to frame a mixed methods study on Indigenous student success at Canadian universities
Designing Your Mixed Methods Study
Step 1: Define Your Research Questions
Mixed methods studies typically have:
- An overarching research question
- Quantitative sub-questions (testing relationships, comparing groups)
- Qualitative sub-questions (exploring experiences, understanding processes)
- A mixed methods question about integration
Step 2: Choose Your Design
Consider:
- Timing: Will you collect data sequentially or concurrently?
- Priority: Will one method be dominant, or will they have equal weight?
- Integration: How and when will you combine data?
- Theoretical lens: Is there an overarching framework guiding the study?
Step 3: Plan Integration
Integration is what distinguishes mixed methods from simply doing two separate studies. Methods include:
- Merging: Comparing quantitative and qualitative findings side by side
- Connecting: Using results from one phase to build the next
- Embedding: Nesting one type of data within a study primarily using another
- Joint displays: Tables or figures that present both types of data together
Step 4: Address Practical Considerations
- Timeline: Sequential designs take longer than concurrent designs
- Skills: Do you have competence in both quantitative and qualitative methods?
- Resources: Mixed methods studies often require more resources
- Ethics: You may need separate ethics protocols for different phases
Canadian Considerations for Mixed Methods Research
Tri-Council Funding
SSHRC, NSERC, and CIHR all fund mixed methods research. When applying:
- Clearly justify why mixed methods is necessary for your questions
- Demonstrate competence in both approaches
- Budget appropriately for both phases
- Address ethical considerations for each component
Bilingual Research
In Canadian contexts, mixed methods designs may involve:
- Surveys in both English and French
- Interviews in participants' preferred language
- Translation and back-translation of instruments
- Analysis of data collected in two languages
Indigenous Mixed Methods
When combining Western research methods with Indigenous methodologies:
- Centre Indigenous knowledge systems as equal to Western approaches
- Follow OCAP® principles for all data
- Engage community throughout the entire research process
- Consider Two-Eyed Seeing as an integrative framework
Reporting Mixed Methods Research
Thesis Structure Options
- Integrated structure: Weaving quantitative and qualitative throughout each chapter
- Separate phases: Dedicating separate chapters to each phase, with an integration chapter
- Manuscript-based: Presenting each phase as a separate paper with an integration paper
Common Reporting Standards
- Follow the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) criteria
- Reference Creswell and Plano Clark's textbook (widely used at Canadian universities)
- Include a visual diagram of your research design
- Clearly describe integration procedures and outcomes
Challenges and Solutions
Challenge: Methodological Expertise
Challenge: Lengthy Timeline
Solution: Be realistic in your proposal; consider concurrent designs if time is limited; plan carefully with milestone deadlines.Challenge: Integration
Solution: Plan integration from the design phase, not as an afterthought; use joint displays to visualise connections between data types.Challenge: Word Count
Solution: Focus on depth of analysis rather than exhaustive description; use appendices for detailed data; consider the manuscript-based thesis format.Conclusion
Mixed methods research offers Canadian graduate students a powerful approach for addressing complex research questions. By thoughtfully combining quantitative and qualitative methods, you can produce research that is both rigorous and richly contextualised.
---
Need guidance designing your mixed methods study? Our methodological experts can help you plan, execute, and integrate quantitative and qualitative components effectively. Contact us for personalised support.
Dr. Amara Osei
Dr. Amara Osei is a qualitative methodologist with a PhD from the University of British Columbia, specialising in narrative inquiry and community-based participatory research.