Introduction: Understanding Research Ethics in Canada
If your thesis or dissertation involves human participants in any capacity, you'll need approval from your institution's Research Ethics Board (REB). Also known as Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) at some institutions, these committees play a crucial role in protecting research participants and ensuring ethical research practices across Canadian universities.
The Canadian research ethics landscape is unique, governed primarily by the Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans (TCPS 2). Understanding this framework and your institution's specific requirements is essential for a smooth approval process.
The TCPS 2: Canada's Research Ethics Framework
The Tri-Council Policy Statement 2 (TCPS 2) is the governing document for research ethics in Canada. Developed jointly by Canada's three federal research agencies—the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC), and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC)—it applies to all research involving human participants at institutions receiving funding from these agencies.
Core Principles of TCPS 2
1. Respect for Persons
This principle recognizes the intrinsic value of human beings and their right to self-determination. In practice, this means:
- Obtaining free, informed, and ongoing consent
- Protecting the welfare of those with diminished capacity to consent
- Respecting participants' privacy and confidentiality
2. Concern for Welfare
Researchers must protect participants from unnecessary risks and consider the impact of research on their physical, mental, spiritual, and social welfare. This includes:
- Minimizing potential harms
- Maximizing potential benefits
- Ensuring fair treatment of participants
3. Justice
Benefits and burdens of research should be distributed fairly. This means:
- Not exploiting vulnerable populations
- Ensuring equitable participant selection
- Making research benefits accessible to those who participated
Types of Ethics Review in Canada
Delegated (Expedited) Review
Minimal-risk research may qualify for delegated review, which is faster than full board review. Research is considered minimal risk when the probability and magnitude of possible harms is no greater than those encountered in everyday life.
Examples of potentially minimal-risk research:
- Anonymous surveys on non-sensitive topics
- Observational studies in public settings
- Secondary analysis of existing datasets
- Interviews on non-sensitive topics with capable adults
Full Board Review
Research involving more than minimal risk requires full REB review. This includes:
- Research with vulnerable populations (children, prisoners, patients)
- Studies involving deception
- Research on sensitive topics (trauma, illegal activities, health conditions)
- Research involving Indigenous communities
- Clinical trials
Course-Based Research
Many Canadian universities have expedited processes for course-based research projects conducted as part of coursework rather than for publication. However, thesis research typically requires standard review even if conducted during coursework.
Preparing Your REB Application
Before You Begin
1. Complete TCPS 2 CORE Training
Most Canadian institutions require completion of the TCPS 2 Course on Research Ethics (CORE) before submitting an REB application. This free online course takes 3-4 hours and provides a certificate upon completion.
2. Consult Your Supervisor
Your supervisor should review your application before submission. They often have experience with the REB process and can identify potential issues early.
3. Review Your Institution's Guidelines
Each Canadian university has specific REB forms, templates, and submission procedures. Familiarize yourself with these before starting your application.
Key Components of Your REB Application
1. Study Description
Provide a clear, jargon-free description of your research that a non-specialist can understand. Include:
- Research questions and objectives
- Background and rationale
- Methodology and procedures
- Timeline
2. Participant Information
Detail who will participate in your study:
- Inclusion/exclusion criteria
- Number of participants
- Recruitment methods
- Vulnerable population considerations
3. Informed Consent Process
Explain how you will obtain and document consent:
- Consent form (in accessible language)
- Information letter for participants
- Process for ongoing consent
- Procedures for participants who wish to withdraw
4. Risk-Benefit Analysis
Honestly assess potential risks and benefits:
- Physical, psychological, social, and economic risks
- Steps to minimize each risk
- Potential benefits to participants and society
- Justification that benefits outweigh risks
5. Privacy and Confidentiality
Describe how you will protect participant information:
- Data collection procedures
- Data storage (physical and digital security)
- Who will have access to identifiable data
- Anonymization or de-identification procedures
- Data retention and destruction plans
6. Data Management Plan
Canadian REBs increasingly require detailed data management plans:
- Where data will be stored (cloud services need Canadian servers for some data)
- Backup procedures
- Long-term data preservation or destruction
Special Considerations for Canadian Researchers
Research Involving Indigenous Peoples
The TCPS 2 includes an entire chapter (Chapter 9) on research involving First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples in Canada. Key requirements include:
• Community engagement: Research should be developed in partnership with Indigenous communities
- Free, prior, and informed consent: From both individuals and communities where appropriate
- Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession (OCAP®): Respecting First Nations principles of data sovereignty
- Cultural protocols: Understanding and respecting specific community protocols
- Benefit sharing: Ensuring research benefits flow back to communities
Multi-Site Research
If your research involves participants at multiple Canadian institutions, you may need:
- Approval from each institution's REB
- A formal inter-institutional agreement
- Designation of a "Board of Record"
International Research
Research conducted outside Canada still requires Canadian REB approval if you're affiliated with a Canadian institution. You may also need:
- Ethical approval from institutions in the host country
- Awareness of local legal requirements
- Cultural considerations in consent processes
Common REB Application Mistakes
1. Insufficient Detail
Problem: Vague descriptions of procedures, risks, or safeguards.
2. Consent Form Issues
Problem: Consent forms that are too long, use jargon, or fail to adequately explain the study. Solution: Write at a Grade 8 reading level. Have someone unfamiliar with your research read the form. Include all required elements per your institution's template.
3. Underestimating Risks
Problem: Claiming research is "no risk" when potential harms exist. Solution: Think carefully about psychological, social, and economic risks, not just physical ones. Discussing past trauma, for example, can cause distress even in interviews.
4. Inadequate Privacy Protections
Problem: Not adequately explaining how participant data will be protected. Solution: Be specific about storage, access, anonymization, and destruction. Consider using pseudonyms rather than participant numbers for qualitative research.
5. Problematic Recruitment
Problem: Recruitment methods that could be coercive (e.g., professors recruiting their own students). Solution: Build in safeguards against real or perceived coercion. Use third-party recruitment where power imbalances exist.
6. Missing Documents
Problem: Incomplete submissions that lack required appendices. Solution: Use a checklist. Include all recruitment materials, interview guides, survey instruments, and consent forms.
Timeline and Planning
Expected Timelines
- Delegated review: 2-4 weeks
- Full board review: 4-8 weeks (boards typically meet monthly)
- Revisions and resubmission: Add 2-4 weeks
Planning Tips
1. Submit early: Build in time for revisions. Most applications require at least one round of revisions.
2. Know meeting dates: Full board reviews are scheduled around monthly meetings. Missing a deadline means waiting another month.
3. Coordinate with your research timeline: You cannot begin recruiting participants until you have approval.
4. Budget for renewal: Ethics approval is typically granted for one year. If your project extends beyond this, you'll need renewal.
Responding to REB Feedback
When you receive feedback from the REB (and you likely will), respond promptly and thoroughly:
1. Address every point: Respond to each concern raised, even if you disagree.
2. Track changes: Submit revised documents with changes highlighted.
3. Write a response memo: Explain how you addressed each concern, point by point.
4. Be professional: Even if feedback seems harsh, respond respectfully. REB members are protecting participants and helping you improve your research.
After Approval
Maintaining Ethical Compliance
Your ethical obligations don't end with approval:
• Follow your approved protocol: Any changes require REB approval before implementation
- Report adverse events: Inform the REB of any unexpected problems
- Renew annually: Submit renewal applications before your approval expires
- Close your file: When research is complete, submit a final report
Amendments
If you need to modify your approved study, submit an amendment application. Common amendments include:
- Changes to recruitment methods
- Revised interview questions
- Extended timelines
- Additional participant populations
Conclusion
The REB process can seem daunting, but it serves an essential purpose in protecting research participants and maintaining the integrity of Canadian research. By understanding the TCPS 2 principles, preparing thoroughly, and responding constructively to feedback, you can navigate the process successfully.
Start early, consult with experienced colleagues and your supervisor, and view the REB as a partner in conducting ethical, high-quality research.
---
Struggling with your REB application? Our team includes former REB members and experienced researchers who can help you prepare a complete, approvable application. Contact us for support.
Dr. Michael Thompson
Dr. Michael Thompson is a former REB member at McGill University with 15 years of experience in research ethics administration and graduate supervision.